Everything is good. Nothing is good

By Ben Supik

As a nutritionist, I’m often asked “Is this a good food for weight loss?”. And the answer is always “Compared to what?”

How good (or useful) a food is to a particular goal is all relative to what you might be eating if you weren’t eating that particular food?

For example, “Are granola bars a good food for weight loss?” Well, if it’s replacing a Snickers Bar, then yes, it’s a good food to sub in compared to the alternative. But if you’re eating the granola bar as a way to justify skipping a salad topped with grilled chicken, then the granola bar is a far inferior option.

This applies to portions as well. When it comes to weight loss, two granola bars in the same sitting are worse than one granola bar. One granola bar is worse than half a granola bar. And (provided you’re not eating something else in its place) zero granola bars is going to be more conducive to weight loss than the half a granola bar.

So next time you see a food touted as being super healthy or great for weight loss, remember that that’s always a context-based description. Ask yourself what you would be eating instead if you weren’t eating that, or how much and how often do you intend to eat it. Keeping this in mind, there are no purely good foods, nor are any purely bad.

Let’s dismiss nutritional duality.


Photo of Author Ben Supik
Ben Supik

Ben Supik founded Activate Body in 2010 after years of working in big box gyms. Learning that sort of place really doesn’t work for a lot of people, Ben set out to start a gym for them: the people that don’t like gyms, but still value living a healthy lifestyle.

Schedule Your Trial!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

2010 Clipper Park Road Suite #115
Baltimore, Maryland 21211
(410) 235-5220
[email protected]


We are open Starting June 29th!
See our COVID page for details and updates

Monday - Thursday: 6:00am - 8:00 pm
Friday: 6:00am - 2:00pm
Saturday & Sunday: 8:00am - 1:00pm

Click for Directions on google maps to Activate Body